conundrum

booger · #1 11-27-2009, 09:19 PM

I currently have a 1999 Specialized FSR that is ready to retire. I'd like to get a new bike but am unsure which route to take. First, I am a bit limited by funds. (I'd like to stay between $900-$1500.) I'm debating whether to buy a new mediocre bike (such as the Rockhopper 29er or similar offerings from other manufacturers) or spend the money on a better used bike. I did find a 2005 Stumpjumper Comp on Craigslist for $900. I really like the bike but am wary of paying that much for worn components. I was hoping to get opinions before making a decision. I do have time to think as winter is just beginning in Michigan. However, I would like to get something new before next summer.

real_ss_budgie · #2 11-28-2009, 02:27 AM

you cant go wrong with new..rochopper29er fullstop

gti2k2000 · #3 11-28-2009, 04:54 AM

Check on E-bay. A few years ago I picked up a Specialized Enduro for half of retail. It was a demo and when I got it, you couldn't tell it had ever been ridden. Sometimes you find good deals. It doesn't cost anything to look.

booger · #4 11-28-2009, 09:20 AM

so basically, avoid the used route...

Teamfubar · #5 11-28-2009, 12:55 PM

The problem with used is that you don't necessarily know what you're getting.

I have one friend that I would have no problem buying something used from. He's good at bike maintenence and takes care of his stuff. He rides hard but also doesn't abuse stuff.

I have a different friend that rides a lot, but isn't hard on equipment, but doesn't do any maintenence. His stuff is usually shanked out even though is isn't necessarily hard on his stuff.

So, on fleaBay, MTBR, Craigs, or even here on the forum, you could be buying from my first friend or my second friend and you'd have no idea.

That all being said, there are some GREAT deals out there and you could get lucky, though luck is what you make it. Ask for a lot of pictures from sellers, ask if they offer any kind of money back/return policy. Ask for pictures of serial numbers. Ask for pictures of the inside of the chainstays (if there is a lot of scuffs/wear, the bike has probably been used in adverse conditions a lot). Look at areas that get a lot of wear like where cables rub the frame, where shoes hit cranks, etc.

On the otherside, buying new you get the peace of mind of no issues and if you do have 'em you have a warranty, you probably will get a 30 day and a 1 year tune up and you have supported your local bike shop.

Plus, unless the used bike is only a year or two old, you're probably getting better technology in a new bike. You're shopping at the right time for a new bike. You could probably find an '09 for closeout pricing, most times the same as the new model, with just a color difference.

Hope this helps. Have fun either way with a new ride!

rockyrider · #6 11-28-2009, 02:04 PM

Anytime you buy a used bike you should assume that you'll need to have the fork and rear shock serviced, might need suspension bushings and bearings and will likely need a new chain, cassette and maybe a chainring or two, all before it's ridable. So that's going to be anywhere from $250-$500. If any of that doesn't need to be done, then it's a bonus.